Logic | Variants | Relevance | Globalisation Constraints | Tendency | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Immigration Regime | Citizenship Regime | Immigration Regime | Citizenship Regime | ||||
Economic logic of the market | Open | Transnational labour markets | High | Low | High | Strong liberal tendency Convergent | |
Closed | Protectionist national labour markets | ||||||
Legal logic of the liberal state | Liberal | Independent and strong judicial review | |||||
Illiberal | Non-independent and weak judicial review | ||||||
Democratic logic of the liberal state | Liberal | Democratic rights extended to immigrants | Low | High | Low | Weak liberal tendency Non-convergent | |
Illiberal | Democratic rights reserved for natives | ||||||
Cultural logic of the nation | Inclusive | Inclusive national identities | |||||
Exclusive | Exclusive national identities |