Web 1.0 (Website A) | Web 2.0 (Facebook group B) | Web 3.0 (Postings on Twitter) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Descriptive Codes | a) Sentiments | ‘puzzled’, ‘confused’, ‘sceptic’ | ‘disgusted’, ‘frustrated’, ‘determined’ | ‘outrageous’, ‘weird’, ‘perplexed’, ‘angry’ |
b) Us vs Them | Korean-German Migrants vs Koreans /Japanese | East Asian (Women) in Germany (or in Europe) vs Germans in Germany | Ethnic/gender minorities in foreign countries vs Racism/Sexism | |
c) Key messages | - Counter argument against negative responses to the ad - Nothing (little) is wrong with the ad | - Empowerment of Asian - Migrants in Europe - Accusation of the message of the ad as stereotyping Asians | - Condemnation of Racism/Sexism in Germany (Europe) - Empowerment of (East) Asians (women) | |
Interpretive Code | d) Tones of voice | Mostly calm, barely using the emotional words or exclamation mark | Emotional words are often used, much more in the 1, 2 phases, relatively less in the 4,5 phases | Highly Emotional, often with aggressive expressions and/or extreme generalisations |
e) Expected Audience | Korean people living in Germany, who may understand both Korean and German cultural contexts | People concerning the issues from Korean- German relations | - People concerning the discrimination issues from all kinds of subjects in the world | |
f) Identity Manifested | - Traditional Korean - Antagonism based on the historical relation with Japan - Naturalised Korean-Germans, having a different identity from Koreans in Korea | - A stereotyped East Asian - Gender minority - Minority amongst other migrants group in Germany | - (East) Asian - Gender Minority - Ethnic Minority - Humans |