Skip to main content

Advertisement

Comparative Migration Studies
Comparative Migration Studies Cover Image

Re-Imagining the Nation

Comparative Migration Studies volume 2, pages9–27 (2014) | Download Citation

Article metrics

Abstract

In the context of immigration and settlement, Canada and Germany are often portrayed as opposites: Canada represents a settler society and Germany an ethnic nation. The different approaches and attitudes of the two countries towards immigration can be linked to different historical understandings of nationhood. Canada could not be imagined as a country without its immigrants; immigration is an integral aspect of national identity. Conversely, although Germany has always received immigrants, national identity has historically been conceived in ethnic terms. In this paper, I explore some of the contradictions in Canadian and German immigration debates related to national belonging. For example, Canada’s identity as a settler society has long marginalized Indigenous populations, while in German debate the narratives of ethnically-belonging Germans and newly-arriving migrants openly engage with each other. By exploring these contradictions, I develop a perspective of the dialectic of migration and ethnic belonging that can be applied to both Canada and Germany.

References

  1. Anderson B. (1991). Imagined communities: reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism. Revised edition. London: Verso.

  2. Anderson B., Sharma N. and Wright C. (2009). Why no borders? Refuge 26(2), 5–18.

  3. Arat-Koç S. (1999). Neo-liberalism, state restructuring and immigration: changes in Canadian policies in the 1990s Journal of Canadian Studies 34(2), 31–56.

  4. Arneil B. (1994). Trade, plantations, and property: John Locke and the economic defense of colonialism. Journal of the History of Ideas 55(4), 591–609.

  5. Assembly of First Nations (2005) Resolution no. 49, Regina. Available at: http://64.26.129.156/article.asp?id=1946 (accessed 30 December 2012)

  6. Bade K. J. (ed.) (1997). Fremde im Land. Osnabrück: Universitätsverlag Rasch.

  7. Bade K. J. (2004). Sozialhistorische Migrationsforschung. Vol. 13, Studien zur historischen Migrationsforschung, ed. Michael Bommes and Jochen Oltmer, Göttingen: V & R Unipress.

  8. Bauböck R. (2003). Reinventing urban citizenship. Citizenship Studies 7(2), 139–160.

  9. Bauder H. (2006a). And the flag waved on: immigrants protest, geographers meet in Chicago. Environment and Planning A 38, 1001–1004.

  10. Bauder H. (2006b). Labor movement: how migration regulates labor markets. New York: Oxford University Press.

  11. Bauder H. (2008a). Kanada: Zuwanderungsmodell für Deutschland? Geographische Rundschau 60(2), 48–50.

  12. Bauder H. (2008b). The economic case for immigration: neoliberal and regulatory paradigms in Canada’s press. Studies in Political Economy 82 (Autumn), 131–152.

  13. Bauder H. (2011a). Closing the immigration-Aboriginal parallax gap. Geoforum 42, 517–519.

  14. Bauder H. (2011b). Immigration dialectic: imagining community, economy and nation. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

  15. Bauder H. (2013). Nation, ‘migration’ and critical practice. Area 45(1), 56–62.

  16. Bauder H. and Semmelroggen J (2009). Immigration and imagination of nationhood in German Parliament. Nationalism & Ethnic Politics 15(1): 1–26.

  17. Bendel P. and Kreienbrink A. (eds.) (2008). Kanada und Deutschland: Migration und Integration im Vergleich. Nürnberg, De: Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge.

  18. Bissoondath N. (1994). Selling illusions: The cult of multiculturalism in Canada. Toronto: Penguin Books.

  19. Castles, S. (2004). Why migration policies fail. Ethnic and Racial Studies 27(2), 205–227.

  20. Cheadle B. (2012). First Nations consulted on 2013 immigration targets as Tories break new ground. Vancouver Sun, September 20. Available at: http://www.vancouversun.com/business/First+Nations+consulted+2013+immigration+targets+Tories+break+ground/7275078/story.html (accessed 30 December 2012).

  21. Coyle J. (2013). Idle No More: a chance to repair a sad legacy. The Toronto Star, 12 January. Available at: www.thestar.com/printarticle/1314325 (accessed January 15, 2013).

  22. Dalton J. E. (2013). Encounters in Canada: contrasting Indigenous and immigrant perspectives. Announcement on POLCAN@listes.ulaval.ca (received January 12, 2013).

  23. Day R. J. F. (2000). Multiculturalism and the history of Canadian diversity. Toronto University of Toronto Press.

  24. Delaney D. and Leitner H. (1997). The political construction of scale. Political Geography 16(2), 93–97.

  25. Denton T. (2011). Personal communication. 31 January.

  26. Foster C. (2007). Blackness and modernity: the colour of humanity and the quest for freedom. Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press.

  27. Gauck J. (2012). Speech at the memorial ceremony of the 20th Anniversary of the anti-foreigner riots in Rostock-Lichtenhagen, 26. August. Available at: http://www.bundespraesident.de/SharedDocs/Reden/DE/Joachim-Gauck/Reden/2012/08/120826-Rostock.html (Accessed 31 October 2012)

  28. Geißler R. (2003). Multikulturalismus in Kanada — Modell für Deutschland? Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte 26, 19–25.

  29. Harles J. (1998). Multiculturalism, national identity, and national integration: the Canadian case. International Journal of Canadian Studies 17, 217–248.

  30. Joppke, C. (2005). Selecting by origin: ethnic migration in the liberal state. Cambridge/Mass.: Harvard University Press.

  31. Kelley N. and Trebilcock M. J. (1998). The making of the mosaic: a history of Canadian immigration policy. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

  32. Knowles V. (1997). Strangers at our gates: Canadian immigration and immigration policy, 1540–1997. Toronto: Dundrun Press.

  33. Kunz J. L. and Sykes S. (2007). From mosaic to harmony: multicultural Canada in the 21st Century — Results of regional roundtables. Ottawa: Government of Canada, Policy Research Initiative.

  34. Légaré E. I. (1995). Canadian multiculturalism and Aboriginal people: negotiating a place in the nation. Identities 1(4), 347–366.

  35. Leo C., August M. and Rogers M. D. (2009). Is the federal government dividing the Aboriginal community? Can it stop? A Winnipeg case study. Paper prepared for the Annual Meeting of the Canadian Political Science Association, Ottawa. Available at: http://blog.uwinnipeg.ca/ChristopherLeo/Cohesion.pdf (accessed 30 December 2012).

  36. Macklem P. (2002). Indigenous difference and the constitution in Canada. University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

  37. Marston S. (2000). The social construction of scale. Progress in Human Geography 24(2), 219–242.

  38. Meier-Braun K.-H. (2002). Deutschland, Einwanderungsland. Frankfurt am Main: Surkamp Verlag.

  39. Minister of Justice (2012). Canadian Multiculturalism Act. Available at: http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/PDF/C-18.7.pdf (last accessed 30 December 2012).

  40. Münz R., Seifert W. and Ulrich R.E. (1999). Zuwanderung nach Deutschland: Strukturen, Wirkungen, Perspektiven. 2nd ed. Frankfurt am Main: Campus Verlag.

  41. Mountz A. and Hyndman J. (2006). Feminist approaches to the global intimate. Women’s Studies Quarterly 34(1/2), 446–463.

  42. Netzwerks Kritische Migrations- und Grenzregimeforschung (Kritnet) (2011) Democracy not integration. Available at: http://demokratie-statt-integration.kritnet.org/demokratie-statt-integration_en.pdf (accessed 26 October, 2012)

  43. No One Is Illegal (2011). On the justice of tearing down fences and dismantling borders. Thursday, April 28. Available at: http://noii-ottawa.blogspot.com/ (accessed Jan. 30, 2012).

  44. Reitz J. G., Frick J. R., Calabrese T. and Wagner G. (1999). The institutional framework of ethnic employment disadvantage: a comparison of Germany and Canada. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 25(3), 397–443.

  45. Sassen S. (2006). Territory, authority, rights: from medieval to global assemblages. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

  46. Saunders D. (2013). What kind of nation is a first nation? We need to decide. The Globe and Mail, 12 January. Available at: http://www.theglobeandmail.com (accessed Jan. 12, 2013)

  47. Sharma N. (2006). Home economics: nationalism and the making of migrant workers in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

  48. Sharma N. and Wright C. (2008–2009). Decolonizing resistance, challenging colonial states. Social Justice 35(3), 120–138.

  49. Schmidtke O. (2010). Einwanderer als Ware: Wie die Marktlogik Migranten aussortiert. Blätter für deutsche und internationale Politik 10, 51–57.

  50. Schultze G. (ed.) (1994). Einwanderungspolitik Kanada’s und der USA: Beispiele für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland? Bonn, DE: Forschungsinstitut der Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung, Apteilung. Arbeits- und Sozailforschung.

  51. Simmons A. B. (1999). Economic integration and designer immigrants: Canadian policy in the 1990s. In Castro M J (ed.) Free markets, open societies, closed borders? Trends in international migration and immigration policy in the Americas (pp. 53–69) Miami, Florida: North-South Center Press.

  52. Soysal Y. N. (1994). Limits of citizenship: migrants and postnational membership in Europe. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

  53. Sterling H. (2012). Two styles of welcoming immigrants. Calgary Herald, 21 December. Available at: http://www.calgaryherald.com (accessed Dec. 21, 2012)

  54. Storr C. and Albrecht R. (2005) Kommentar zum Zuwanderungsgesetz, Stuttgart: Boorberg Verlag.

  55. Taylor P. J. (1994). The state as container: territoriality in the modern world-system. Progress in Human Geography 18(2), 151–162.

  56. Triadafilopoulos P. (2004). Building walls, bounding nations: migration and exclusion in Canada and Germany, 1870 1939. Journal of Historical Sociology 17(4), 385–427.

  57. Triadafilopoulos P. (2006). A model for Europe? An appraisal of Canadian integration policies. In Baringhorst S, Hunger U and Schönwälder K (eds.) Politische Steuerung von Integrationsprozessen: Intentionen und Wirkungen (pp. 79–94). Wiesbaden, DE: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.

  58. Triadafilopoulos P. (2012). Becoming multicultural: Immigration and the politics of membership in Canada and Germany. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.

  59. Tully J. (1993). An Approach to Political Philosophy: Locke in Context, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

  60. Turner D. (2006). This is not a peace pipe: towards a critical Indigenous philosophy. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

  61. Varsanyi M. W. (2006). Interrogating “urban citizenship” vis-à-vis undocumented migration. Citizenship Studies 10(2), 229–249.

  62. Wengeler M. (1995). Multikulturelle Gesellschaft oder Ausländer raus? Der sprachliche Umgang mit der Einwanderung seit 1945. In Stötzel G, Wengeler M and Böke K (eds.) Kontroverse Begriffe: Geschichte des öffentlichen Sprachgebrauchs in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland (pp. 711–749). Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.

  63. Wimmer A. and Glick Schiller N. (2002). Methodological nationalism and beyond: nation-state building, migration and the social sciences. Global Networks 2(4), 301–334.

  64. Winter E. (2001). National unity versus multiculturalism? Rethinking the logic of inclusion in Germany and Canada. International Journal of Canadian Studies — Revue Internationale d’études Canadiennes 24, 171–195.

  65. Winter E. (2007). Bridging unequal relations, ethnic diversity, and the dream of unified nationhood: multiculturalism in Canada. Zeitschriftfür Kanada-Studien 1, 38–57.

  66. Zentralstelle für die Weiterbildung im Handwerk (ZWH) (2009) To Canada migration nach Deutschland. Düsseldorf.

  67. Žižek S. (2006). The parallax view. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press.

Download references

Author information

Affiliations

  1. Professor of Geography, Academic Director, Department of Geography and Graduate Program in Immigration and Settlement Studies, Ryerson University, Toronto, Canada

    • Harald Bauder

Authors

  1. Search for Harald Bauder in:

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Harald Bauder.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Keywords

  • immigration
  • migration
  • settler society
  • ethnic nation
  • national imagination
  • Indigenous
  • nationhood
  • dialectic
  • Canada
  • Germany